Useful journalism to understand, manage and grow a business.
Search**OTAs** offer global visibility but charge commissions of **15% to 30%**, while a hotel’s own channel retains guest data and reduces acquisition costs. This analysis details how to use the **billboard effect** to turn third-party traffic into profitable direct bookings through key metrics such as **COA**.
The relationship between independent hotels and Online Travel Agencies (OTAs) is complex. On the one hand, platforms such as Booking.com and Expedia provide invaluable visibility, especially for properties without an established brand or during low seasons. On the other, distribution commissions, which usually range from 15% to 30% of the booking value, significantly erode profit margins. The strategic question is not whether to eliminate these platforms, but how to achieve a healthy balance that maximizes profitability without sacrificing booking volume.
To understand the scale of the financial impact, it is necessary to analyze the Cost of Acquisition (COA) by channel. Unlike OTAs, where the hotel pays a fixed commission for each transaction, the direct channel has variable costs associated with digital marketing, the booking engine, and payment processing. According to industry data, the average acquisition cost in the direct channel is between 4% and 5%.
Consider a booking of 200 USD per night:
This difference of 30 USD per booking may seem modest, but across 500 bookings in a quarter, it represents an additional 15,000 USD retained. In addition, the direct channel offers greater control over cash flow, allowing for immediate payment compared with the payment delays of some OTAs.
A common mistake is to perceive OTAs as direct competitors. Research from Cornell University identifies the phenomenon known as the "Billboard Effect." Studies indicate that 75% of consumers who book on a brand’s website had previously visited an OTA. In an analysis of 1,720 transactions, it was found that for every booking made on Expedia, the brand’s website received between 3 and 9 additional bookings.
This means that OTAs act as a discovery engine. 65% of direct bookings come from guests who first saw the hotel on a third-party platform. The key strategy is not to abandon OTAs, but to capture these "window shoppers" when they arrive at the hotel’s own website. The goal is to turn the visibility generated by third parties into a direct, profitable relationship.
To adjust their strategy, managers must look beyond occupancy or ADR (Average Daily Rate). COA is the metric that answers the critical question: How much of my revenue am I giving away just to get the booking?
Another decisive metric is the cancellation rate. In some markets, cancellations through OTAs reach 37%, compared with 18%–20% for direct bookings. A higher cancellation rate means greater inventory risk and more staff time devoted to managing rebookings, negatively affecting operational efficiency.
| Metric | OTA Channel | Direct Channel | Impact on Profitability |
|---|---|---|---|
| Commission/Cost | 15%–30% | 2%–5% | Higher gross margin for direct bookings |
| Guest Data | Masked (e.g., guest@ota.com) | Owned (real email) | Opportunity for loyalty and remarketing |
| Cancellation Rate | Up to 37% | 18%–20% | Lower inventory risk for direct bookings |
| Brand Control | Low | High | Personalized experience and upselling |
To reduce dependence on OTAs and increase the share of direct bookings, the following strategic actions are proposed:
Direct bookings are not just an option, but a necessity for the financial sustainability of independent hotels. The direct channel offers the lowest acquisition cost, greater control over the guest experience, and the foundation for sustainable profitability. The optimal strategy is to use OTAs to generate visibility and baseline demand while investing in strategies that direct that traffic to the hotel’s own channel, turning third-party guests into loyal, direct customers.
Practical guide for SMEs: define objectives, assign specific functions to each message, and automate the sequence to turn the first impression into a sustainable business relationship.
Read story
A campaign can generate sales and still lose money. Learn how to calculate ROI with full costs, distinguish it from ROAS and CAC, and track results with accessible tools.
Read story
A practical guide to understanding reach, impressions, engagement, CTR, KPIs, leads, and conversions, and how to use each data point according to your company's marketing objectives.
Read story